Southern pike (Esox cisalpinus): the pike that only became a species of its own in 2011

If you catch a pike in the Po Valley, on Lake Trasimeno or in Ticino, there may not be an *Esox lucius* on your hook at all. Since 2011 the pike of northern and central Italy has been considered a species of its own: *Esox cisalpinus*, in English southern pike or cisalpine pike (English Wikipedia, GBIF), in German Italienischer Hecht (German Wikipedia), in Italian luccio italico or luccio cisalpino (Italian Wikipedia), in French brochet italien (French Wikipedia, GBIF), in Spanish lucio cisalpino (Spanish Wikipedia), in Finnish italianhauki (Finnish Wikipedia). It grows to 103 cm (FishBase) and looks deceptively similar to the pike you know from central and northern Europe. Here is what the sources know about it, how to recognise it and where they contradict each other.

One species, two names

In 2011 two research groups independently reached the same conclusion. Pier Giorgio Bianco and Giovanni Battista Delmastro described the species as *Esox cisalpinus* in an overview of Italy's native freshwater fishes. Shortly afterwards Lucentini and colleagues published the same species in the journal *PLoS ONE* as *Esox flaviae* — with Lake Trasimeno in Umbria as the type locality. Because Bianco and Delmastro's work was printed first, the rule of priority makes *cisalpinus* the valid name; *flaviae* is a junior synonym (German, English and Finnish Wikipedia; FishBase calls *flaviae* “probably” a synonym). The rejected name has a story of its own: according to their paper, Lucentini and colleagues dedicated it to Flavia, the name of the first women of the Flavian imperial dynasty, to emphasise the species’ “Latin” origin. *Cisalpinus* literally means “on this side of the Alps” — seen from Rome, that is, south of them.

How to tell it from the northern pike

  • Stripes instead of round spots. The colouring is highly variable: longitudinal stripes, vertical bands, oblique stripes or a star-like branching pattern, dark on a lighter background (German and English Wikipedia). According to German Wikipedia it never shows the round pale spots typical of the northern pike — English Wikipedia sees it differently, more on that below.
  • Striped when young, marbled when old. In juveniles the oblique bands are distinct; in adults they merge into a worm-like or marbled pattern (Italian Wikipedia), while the body darkens from whitish to green (English Wikipedia).
  • Unpaired fins almost without pattern. According to Italian Wikipedia they lack the worm-like lines; there are only a few scattered dark eyespots.
  • Fewer scales along the lateral line than in the northern pike — the most important countable feature. The exact numbers differ between the sources (see below).
  • Four instead of five pores under the lower jaw on each side (English and Italian Wikipedia).
  • Fin formula: dorsal fin i–ii/13–16, anal fin i–ii/11–13, caudal fin 14–18 rays; 13–14 branchiostegal rays (German Wikipedia).
  • Pike shape: elongated, flat duck-bill snout, large mouth with many sharp teeth, dorsal and anal fins set far back (German Wikipedia).

From the Po Valley to Lago di Fondi

According to Italian Wikipedia the species is recorded throughout northern Italy in the Po-Venetian plain and in central Italy from the Magra basin to Lago di Fondi. English Wikipedia names Veneto, Emilia-Romagna, Tuscany and Lazio as the core of its native range. Through stocking it also reached Campania (Lago del Matese), Molise and Sardinia, as well as some French lakes (Italian Wikipedia). Besides northern and central Italy, French Wikipedia names Ticino, which belongs to the Po basin. Whether pike on the north-eastern Adriatic or in southern France also belong to this species is an open question (FishBase, German and Italian Wikipedia). And because Italian pike were shipped to other countries for a long time, according to English Wikipedia the species also lives far outside Italy: specimens went to Spain, Portugal, Algeria, Morocco, Tunisia, Ethiopia and Madagascar, among other places.

Habitat, prey, spawning season

  • Clear, still or slow-flowing water with plants. The species needs aquatic vegetation in which it hunts and spawns (Italian Wikipedia); it lives in clear, weedy lakes and rivers (German Wikipedia).
  • Ambush predator near the bottom. Hungarian Wikipedia describes it as a predatory fish that attacks from cover; FishBase lists it as benthopelagic, in temperate fresh water.
  • Prey: fish, including smaller members of its own species, plus frogs and crayfish (German and English Wikipedia). It is solitary and territorial (German Wikipedia).
  • Matures early. Males reproduce at one year, females at two years (German, English and Finnish Wikipedia). FishBase gives a length at maturity from 30 cm.
  • Spawning season by region. In central Italy February to March, in northern Italy March to April (German, English and Finnish Wikipedia).
  • Age: at most 13 years (FishBase).

Threatened by its own relative

On the IUCN Red List *Esox cisalpinus* is listed as Vulnerable (assessed on 26 September 2023; according to FishBase). According to Italian Wikipedia the greatest danger is hybridisation with stocked northern pike, along with overfishing and habitat loss. In some lakes of central Italy — Lago di Chiusi, Lago di Piediluco and Lago Recentino are named — the species is said to be already heavily mixed with *Esox lucius*. Lucentini and colleagues therefore closed their paper with a clear demand: no more stocking of northern pike in southern Europe, because of the risk of hybridisation. In practice there is an added difficulty: because the species was only split off in 2011, many fish distribution maps of northern Italy still list it as *Esox lucius* (Italian Wikipedia).

Where the sources contradict each other

  • Never or sometimes round spots? German Wikipedia: it never shows the round spots of the northern pike. Finnish Wikipedia: usually not. English Wikipedia: a variant with pale round spots on a dark background does occur — probably through crossing with stocked northern pike, as it appears mainly where stocking took place.
  • How many scales along the lateral line? English and Italian Wikipedia: 92 to 107. German Wikipedia: 101 to 115. For the northern pike, English Wikipedia gives 105 to 148, German Wikipedia 125 to 148.
  • How big does it get? FishBase and Hungarian Wikipedia: 103 cm. German and Finnish Wikipedia: about one metre. Spanish Wikipedia: at most 35 cm — a figure that matches no other source.
  • Does Lake Geneva belong? English Wikipedia: historical specimens from south-eastern France and Lake Geneva have been assigned to this species. French Wikipedia: today it lives exclusively in northern and central Italy and in Ticino. Italian Wikipedia: stocking in some French lakes.
  • Synonym certain or probable? German, English and Finnish Wikipedia call *Esox flaviae* a synonym. FishBase only says “probably”. Hungarian Wikipedia notes that other Wikipedias in some cases still list *cisalpinus* as a synonym of *Esox lucius*.

Two traps with the name

  • “Luccio” doesn’t automatically mean northern pike. Many fish distribution maps and older texts from Italy say *Esox lucius*, but often mean the southern pike (Italian Wikipedia). Conversely, where stocking took place, there really may be a northern pike or a hybrid in the water.
  • “Southern pike” is not a catch-all term. The English name means this one species, not pike from the south in general; Lucentini and colleagues proposed it for *E. flaviae*, i.e. for the same fish.

Which brings us to the when, the question every article in this series ends with. For *Esox cisalpinus* the sources give a clear pointer: spawning happens early in the year, in central Italy in February and March, in northern Italy in March and April — check the local closed seasons before you go fishing. On feeding times, the sources read here say nothing. Habitat, prey and features are covered above, as far as they are documented. What changes every day are the conditions on your water — StrikeAhead calculates them and tells you when the trip is worth it. And because you don’t know the drop-offs and rules of an unfamiliar water from day one, StrikeAhead Pathfinder tells you who to go out with: curated guides and skippers, personally vetted before listing — licence and insurance —, with verified catches instead of promo photos, no paid ranking and, for you as an angler, no booking fee. The app tells you when, Pathfinder tells you with whom.